Tuesday, May 5, 2009


The New York State Assembly’s Republican conference recently held another panel on how to stop the ‘brain drain’ as part of its “RemaiNY” initiative. This time, the events were held on Long Island, but previous forums were held in Upstate, which would seem more appropriate given the exodus of recent college grads from Upstate’s communities. In any case, over the past twenty years much has been made of the so-called ‘brain drain’.

But the issue always seems to be framed as if it were the responsibility of Upstate NY’s communities to adapt themselves to the needs of the young, ambitious and college-educated, when perhaps it should be the other way around. I look at everything that Upstate New York has to offer: a moderate climate, some of the most beautiful natural landscapes in the world, an extremely low cost of living, and some of the nations’ oldest and richest historical communities. I then have to wonder what it is exactly that the people leaving in droves are hoping to find.

Well you can get your answer by looking at the places these people are leaving for, i.e. New York City, Boston and Chicago metro regions. What do these places have that we don’t, besides heavy suburban sprawl, traffic-choked highways and gentrifying (read: unaffordable) inner city neighborhoods? Well, contrary to conventional wisdom, it’s not a lack of jobs that drives these people away from Upper New York, it’s a lack of jobs that pay a ton of money to fuel an obsession with status and material acquisition that has become the standard of the American way of life.

A person can easily live in a city like Amsterdam or Utica on minimum wage (maybe with a little help in the form of food stamps, WIC and Medicaid). But what, that’s not good enough?

That these people don’t want to live in MY Upstate NY is not something I consider a problem and I don’t believe that we should waste one second thinking about how to keep these people in this state. Let them go off and join their rat race. Good riddance!


Anonymous said...

You just said that upstate New York has "an extremely low cost of living.” How the hell did you come up with that brilliant analysis? New York State usually ranks in the worst 10% of states in the nation when it comes to cost of living, no matter whose survey you look at. When you factor in the extremely oppressive state government and all the other “perks” you get in this state, by some analyses New York ranks #1 as the WORST place to live. Do you live in a bubble? According to the “Tax Foundation” organization (google it), New York ranks #49, beat out by only New Jersey in their “2009 State Business Tax Climate Index”. Like it or not, if businesses can't survive here, neither can people. Maybe you think that “the young, ambitious and college-educated” “can easily live in a city like Amsterdam or Utica on minimum wage (maybe with a little help in the form of food stamps, WIC and Medicaid)”, but I think there are better options for them. The number one option is to get out of this God-forsaken state while they still can.

Anonymous said...

Your post proves the point that the only people left Upstate are (a) retired, (b) on welfare, (c) government employees, which is really the same as (b), or (d) dumb as a rock. Of the 20 counties in the U.S. with the highest property taxes relative to property value, 19 are in Upstate NY. So much for that "low cost of living."

Sean said...

Well your post proves absolutely nothing and instead repeats the same demeaning stereotypes about Upstate NY and its people.

Not that it matters anyway, in ten years this whole country is going to look like Amsterdam and Utica.

Anonymous said...

This is my first post I'd like to thank you for such a terrific quality site!
I was sure this is a nice way to introduce myself!

Edwyn Sammy
if you're ever bored check out my site!
[url=http://www.partyopedia.com/articles/hot-wheels-party-supplies.html]hot wheels Party Supplies[/url].

Anonymous said...

This is my first post I'd like to congratulate you for such a terrific made forum!
Was thinking this is a nice way to introduce myself!
When trying to collect revenue it is usually a good idea to start a savings or investing strategy as early in life as imaginable. But don't fear if you have not started saving your money until later on in life. As a result of hard work, that is investigating the best investment vehicles for your capital you can slowly but surely increase your funds so that it extends to a large amount by the period you want to retire. Scout out all of the accessible asset classes from stocks to real estate as investments for your money. A well diversified portfolio of investments in a wide range of asset classes may help your money enlarge throughout the years.

-Avis Christon
[url=http://urwealthy.com]currency exchange rates[/url]